Thursday, July 2, 2009

Can't Get Through

A wise man distrusts his neighbor. A wiser man distrusts both his neighbor and himself. The wisest man of all distrusts his government. –“The Devil’s Advocate”
If we are allowed to stay free, we must see to it that the right to bear computers becomes as inalienable as the constitutional guarantees of free speech and a free press. -Timothy Leary
Anybody there?
It’s been awhile since my last blog, but I’m still alive and well in the People’s Republic of China. Nothing extraordinary to relate, but it is often the accumulation of smaller things that make up a life.
I am writing this blog on the 20th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre. When you can actually read it, well, that’s a different story.* To mute discussions of this event, the Chinese government has blocked a variety of websites including BlogSpot, Hotmail, Twitter and Flickr.
The emphasis of this shutdown seems to be on communication, rather than information. I can still access Google, and read the articles about Tiananmen that are circulating in the western press. The government’s primary concern seems to be that people will engage in active communication and dialogue.
The media in China (television, newspapers, radio) is either State-run or State-controlled. And the Party line has been to ignore the anniversary.
Sounds grim, doesn’t it? But it doesn’t feel grim, and that is the insidiousness of the situation.
Bear with me as I offer my own analysis, keeping in mind that I am limited by scope of my experience.
Today, 20 years after Tiananmen, China is in a different position, both economically and in its relationship with the international world. There is more freedom for the average citizen and more prosperity (relatively speaking) across the country. Thus the severities of the conditions that led to the ’89 protests have lessened. This has resulted in an illusion of freedom without really changing the structural core.
Have you read the book, The Devil’s Advocate? This is not the movie with Keanu Reeves, but a much earlier manuscript written by novelist Taylor Caldwell. It takes place in an America that has evolved into a land without freedom. The people are oppressed, but they are not oppressed quite so much that they are willing to challenge the government. Freedom-loving rebels do not have the numbers for open rebellion, so they work their way into high positions within the system. In their positions of power, they act not to increase freedom but to make the oppression even more unbearable. Eventually, the population rebels and overthrows the government.
In my estimation, the people of China have been given a larger cage. The standard of living has increased, and most of today’s youth are apolitical. They are more concerned with finding a high-paying job than about their degree of freedom. Of course, maybe they are not so much apathetic as they are calculating. It is possible that they have decided the risks of protest are not worth taking. It is possible, but I still lean towards explanation number one.
I think that the young people of China today feel freer than they truly are, and that a bit of the Emperor’s New Clothes phenomena helps to keep that feeling in place. There is also a sense of innocence and naiveté.
At the other end of the spectrum, I look at elderly faces around me and can only imagine what things they have lived through. The cultural revolution, the Great Leap Forward…. Innocence was not a luxury given to this generation in China.
But China has been evolving as a social and political entity for a long, long time. As a newcomer to this country, it is hard to decipher what conditions are blips in time, and which are deeper manifestations of the cultural psyche.
The world as a whole is also evolving. Whether it is embraced or resisted, communication technology is impacting the globe socially, politically and economically. Ultimately, as China’s population becomes increasingly well-informed, it will be the people themselves who determine if freedom is important. They will also have to determine how high a price they are willing to pay for it.
I find the psychological pulse here very interesting, but also very resistant to a definitive grasp. It’s not that the Chinese are inscrutable, but rather that, like all of us, they are complex. And the roots of their complexities are different enough from my own experiences so that understanding is earned slowly.
*Note: As of one week ago, Blogspot was still unaccessible in China. I'm writing this from the States.

No comments: